New York City is preparing to send out pied-à-terre tax bills to approximately 8,000 homeowners, a significantly lower figure than initially anticipated. This development represents a shortfall for Mayor Zohran Mamdani's luxury second home tax and its projected revenue.
The city had initially sent out around 17,000 notices in August to properties valued over $5 million (or co-ops over $1 million), informing owners they might be subject to the surcharge unless they could prove primary residency. However, the Department of Finance received over 10,000 exemption requests, of which at least 8,900 were granted. This leaves an estimated 8,100 properties expected to receive the actual tax bills, a number that could still fluctuate.
Mamdani and New York Gov. Kathy Hochul had announced the controversial tax, which they projected would generate over $500 million annually. The lower-than-expected number of tax bills is seen as a blow to these projections.
This situation follows a recent ruling by an appeals court in Brooklyn that allowed the rollout of the pied-à-terre tax to proceed, a decision that had been a victory for Mamdani. The lawsuit challenging the tax was filed by a group of homeowners who argued the rollout was "arbitrary and capricious," though not the tax itself. Mamdani expressed optimism about the ruling and stated he looked forward to defending the policy in future proceedings.