Mystic, Connecticut, has been recognized as the best destination for dining in the United States, according to a recent Travel + Leisure report. Located approximately 2.5 hours from New York City, the seaside town has evolved from its namesake pizzeria fame into a culinary hub, attracting visitors with its focus on fresh, local seafood and a growing number of James Beard Award-recognized chefs.
Mystic's maritime history has long drawn vacationers, but its recent culinary ascent is attributed to a commitment to sourcing beyond traditional fried offerings. The town boasts a collaborative network of chefs, bartenders, farmers, and fishermen who contribute to its vibrant food scene. "This corner of Connecticut is practically overflowing with award-winning chefs, imaginative bartenders, hard-working farmers, knowledgeable servers, and expert fishermen. What’s more: They all intersect in Mystic because of the area’s fertile farmland and bountiful waters," the outlet stated.
Among the notable establishments is The Port of Call, recognized for its beverage program. Nearby, Shipwright’s Daughter, a waterfront restaurant, bases its daily menu on the catches brought in by local fishermen. The kitchen is led by James Beard Award winner David Standridge, whose menu features dishes like kelp-wrapped scallops and seared squid. Standridge, who also owns Mystic Fish Camp, emphasizes a sustainable approach, sourcing ingredients from local purveyors.
Oyster Club, another recommended spot, specializes in bivalves, serving oysters from across New England with various house-made accompaniments. The restaurant also features an outdoor dining area known as the Treehouse, overlooking the Mystic River.
For those interested in artisanal baked goods, Nana’s Bakery offers sourdough loaves, pizzas, and its popular sourdoughnuts. Mediterranean-inspired Barbary Coast provides a menu of shareable dishes, including a tahini Caesar salad and moussaka made with local lamb, complemented by a natural wine list.
The town has also seen a rise in hospitality options. The Delamar Mystic, which opened last year, offers waterfront views and amenities like complimentary breakfast. The Whaler’s Inn has expanded with the addition of The Stanton House, featuring accommodations such as the Riverview Penthouse, with room service available from Shipwright’s Daughter.
Experts suggest that Mystic offers appeal beyond the summer months, with its culinary attractions available year-round. For those seeking a quieter experience, staying in nearby Stonington Borough is recommended, offering a peaceful retreat before or after visiting Mystic's attractions like the Mystic Seaport.