A former Coast Guard petty officer has been freed after a six-year legal battle surrounding the death of her infant daughter. Katie Richard, 30, was the primary suspect in the death of her five-month-old daughter, Scarlett, who was found dead in her crib in April 2020.

Prosecutors alleged that Richard had suffocated the baby by pushing her face into the crib's mattress. Her defense lawyers, however, contended that Scarlett may have succumbed to sudden infant death syndrome (SIDS). Medical analysis from the hospital where Scarlett died also suggested SIDS, with one doctor noting no suspicion of abuse and that the parents were understandably devastated.

Richard was stationed in Kodiak, Alaska, at the time of her daughter's death. She told The Washington Post that she found her infant child unresponsive after going out to buy coffee while her then-husband remained at home. She recounted the immediate shock and pain of discovering her daughter's condition.

Following Scarlett's death, military investigators questioned Richard extensively, including an hour-long interrogation two months after the infant's passing. A recording of Richard stating she "might have" pushed her baby's face into the mattress as she put her down to sleep was played during her initial trial, leading to her incarceration.

Richard was sentenced in 2022 and served two years in a military prison, first at the Navy brig in Chesapeake, Virginia, and later at the Navy brig in Miramar, California. She described the emotional toll of being perceived as guilty by others while knowing her innocence.

In 2024, a military appeals court overturned her conviction, finding the manslaughter charge, added to charges of first-degree murder and obstruction of justice, unjustifiable. The court did not specify the alleged actions leading to asphyxia. Two months later, Richard was released from prison.

Despite her release, the Coast Guard charged her again in 2025 with involuntary manslaughter. Richard appealed, citing the double jeopardy clause of the Fifth Amendment, but her petition was denied. Her second trial commenced at Coast Guard Base Portsmouth, Virginia, and lasted two months.

In April, Richard was found not guilty of manslaughter. In September, she received $168,000 in back pay, minus taxes, for her time spent in prison. Now divorced and living in Hawaii, Richard aims to move forward and grieve properly, acknowledging that she can never recover her daughter or the lost years.

A spokesperson for the US Coast Guard stated that the service retried Richard after her conviction was set aside on appeal, as the appellate court specifically authorized a rehearing. The spokesperson added that the Coast Guard Investigative Service is required to investigate all deaths within their jurisdiction and that agents are trained to conduct thorough, objective investigations, respecting the court-martial panel's findings.

Katie Richard, 30, was the primary suspect in the tragic death of her five-month-old daughter, Scarlett