MS NOW’s Nicolle Wallace presented a montage featuring several high-profile individuals who were once staunch supporters of Donald Trump but have since voiced significant criticism or regret. The compilation showcased what Wallace described as "some of the contortions that Trump has forced some of his most rabid followers to make, in their own words."

The clips highlighted a perceived split within the MAGA movement, with former allies like Marjorie Taylor Greene and Tucker Carlson reportedly exploring the idea of forming a new political party. The montage included instances of former supporters expressing strong negative sentiments towards Trump.

Conspiracy theorist Alex Jones, who previously advocated for supporting Trump to prevent societal collapse, was shown calling for Trump's removal from office via the 25th Amendment. Candace Owens, initially a vocal supporter, expressed embarrassment over her past endorsement, stating Trump "completely flipped on his entire base." Podcaster Shawn Ryan claimed he "never even wanted Trump to win" until Trump became the only option. MMA fighter Sean Strickland, who had previously praised Trump, was featured comparing the atmosphere at a Trump rally to the conditions that led to the rise of Hitler.

Following the montage, political analyst Rick Stengel suggested that some of the criticism indicated "the proverbial rats deserting the sinking ship." He noted that these individuals are leaving for various reasons, and some believe Trump should be acting more radically. Stengel concluded that many featured in the montage feel betrayed by Trump, believing he lacks a consistent ideology beyond seeking attention and financial gain.