Mayor Zohran Mamdani has appointed five new judges to the Criminal Court, with a significant number having backgrounds as public defenders, a move that critics contend will lead to more lenient sentencing and compromise public safety.
Mamdani named his first five Criminal Court picks on Monday, three of whom are career public defenders. Only two of the appointees have prior experience as prosecutors. Additionally, at least three of his five Family Court selections also have strong Legal Aid backgrounds, and three of his six reappointments to the bench have defense attorney experience.
One notable reappointment is Manhattan Criminal Court Judge Valentina Morales, referred to by critics as “Judge Cut ’Em Loose.” According to the report, Morales had a high release rate of 82% for individuals arraigned on violent felony charges in the first six months of 2024.
Queens Criminal Court Judge Jennifer Saint-Preux, a former Legal Aid lawyer, was also reappointed. The report notes an instance in August where she ordered serial offender Shaquan Seth, who had faced nearly 150 arrests, held on $100,000 bond despite prosecutor pleas for stricter measures.
These appointments mark the first judicial selections made by Mamdani, following a dozen choices vetted under the previous mayor. The Criminal Court bench consists of 107 judges, each serving a 10-year term, suggesting a long-term impact of these appointments.
Critics suggest that judges with public defender backgrounds may be more inclined to favor counseling over incarceration for defendants and may be less likely to order bail for the accused. This approach, they argue, could lead to more career criminals remaining free, particularly as the city anticipates a reduction in jail space under the proposed plan to replace Rikers Island and with the mayor's stance on expanding the police force. Mamdani's office has not yet released a statement regarding these concerns. The selections signal a potential shift in the court's approach to criminal justice, with critics warning of negative consequences for public safety.