Manchester United concluded their pre-season campaign with a concerning 4-2 defeat against AC Milan, a result that exposed significant challenges for manager Michael Carrick just a week before the Premier League season commences.
Despite an early lead from Harry Maguire, United struggled to assert control against a dynamic Milan side. Goals from Samuel Chukwueze, Alphadjo Cisse, Goncalo Ramos, and Ruben Loftus-Cheek ultimately secured the victory for AC Milan, managed by Ruben Amorim, who secured a victory against his former club.
Defensive Frailties on the Left Flank
A prominent area of concern highlighted in the match was the left-back position. Milan consistently exploited space on United's left side, with Chukwueze instrumental in creating chances. He provided the assist for Cisse's equalizer and set up Ramos for the third goal. Loftus-Cheek also broke free down the same flank to score Milan's fourth.
With plans for Harry Amass's departure this summer and reliance solely on Luke Shaw, who is showing signs of aging, United's left-back situation is considered a significant gamble. Manager Carrick acknowledged the need for reinforcements in this area before the September 1 transfer deadline, emphasizing that failure to acquire a new left-back will require creative solutions.
Need for Midfield Dynamism
Beyond defense, Manchester United also requires greater dynamism and energy in central midfield. While Andrey Santos impressed during pre-season and Youri Tielemans showed flashes of form, the partnership was not consistently effective. The notes suggest that even with the returning Kobbie Mainoo, the team needs a midfielder capable of covering more ground and compensating for deficiencies in players like Tielemans.
United's initial plan to add three midfielders was reportedly cooled due to Mason Mount's early pre-season form. However, Mount did not feature in this match after an early exit in a previous game. With director of football Jason Wilcox in attendance, the team's midfield struggles were evident, suggesting that United could be too easily bypassed if improvements are not made.
Marcus Rashford's Return and Future
Marcus Rashford made his first appearance since December 2024, wearing the No. 9 shirt, although official squad numbers for the season remain undecided. His return offered moments of purpose and excitement, despite speculation about his potential departure.
United has been reportedly open to offers for the attacker, but any transfer would need to align with both the player's preferences and the club's valuation. If Rashford remains at United, Carrick's task will be to integrate him effectively and maximize his contribution to the team's project.
Carrick's Style of Play Under Scrutiny
AC Milan's ability to stifle Manchester United's attack and control possession raised concerns about the team's offensive fluidity. United was often perceived as lethargic and static with the ball, while mistakes were prevalent when out of possession.
In contrast to earlier pre-season performances against Atletico Madrid, PSG, and Leeds United, which showcased pace and sharp passing, this match saw a decline in intensity and energy. Carrick's preferred high-intensity, high-energy style of play was notably absent. The performance suggests a clear blueprint for opponents like Hull City: slow United down to exploit their weaknesses, mirroring Milan's successful strategy.