A federal judge in Maine ruled Friday that the Hermon School Committee discriminated against The Pines Church of Bangor after its pastor requested a yearlong lease to hold Sunday services at Hermon High School. The ruling stated that religious bias influenced the committee's decision.

In 2022, the church's lead pastor, Matt Gioia, approached the Hermon School Department to discuss renting space in the high school for Sunday worship services, seeking a yearlong lease rather than a month-to-month arrangement.

Following Gioia's proposal presentation, committee member Christopher McLaughlin inquired through then-Superintendent Micah Grant about how the church approached "issues of diversity, equity and inclusion around their messaging around some key issues relevant to marginalized communities." These questions also addressed the church's stances on same-sex marriage, abortion, and transgender issues.

Chief U.S. District Judge Lance Walker noted in his decision that while Superintendent Grant did not exhibit bias, at least three school committee members—McLaughlin, Stephanie Oiler, and Karen Shorey—were improperly influenced by the church's religious identity or beliefs. "I conclude that this qualifies as a sufficient ‘bad motive’ for First Amendment purposes as it has been interpreted and applied by the Supreme Court," Walker wrote regarding Oiler's conduct, adding that McLaughlin would have approached the lease request differently had it been from an organization sharing his personal beliefs.

Walker determined that the school department's treatment and denial of the church's yearlong lease application violated its First Amendment rights and Maine's public accommodations law. However, the judge denied the church's request for a court order to block future lease denials, finding that the church's attorneys had not established the school's written rental policy was unconstitutional or met the legal requirements for an injunction.

Hermon School Superintendent Barbara Sargent stated that the department is reviewing the decision and will consider adjusting its procedures. "The department is committed to ensuring that this resolution does not distract from our essential work," Sargent said. "We remain focused on providing an exceptional educational experience, supporting our professional staff, and maintaining a school environment where student success is the highest priority."

Advocates for Faith & Freedom, which represented the church, praised the ruling. "This ruling affirms a fundamental principle: When public schools open their facilities to community groups such as sports teams, scouts and recreation programs, they cannot exclude churches simply because of their faith," said Bob Tyler, president of Advocates for Faith & Freedom. "The Constitution demands neutrality, and today the court enforced it."