Sir Ian Botham has initiated a campaign, named 'Not One Moor,' to protest against proposed wind turbine projects in four Northern English counties. The campaign targets plans for 94 turbines, some reaching up to 230 meters in height, which Botham argues would devastate scenic landscapes in County Durham, Northumberland, Lancashire, and West Yorkshire.
Botham contends that these turbines, significantly taller than Nelson's Column, would be visible for dozens of miles, impacting areas such as Barningham Moor, Ray Fell, Scout Moor, and Walshaw Moor. He asserts that the projects are being designated as Nationally Significant Infrastructure Projects to bypass local planning regulations, a move he believes undermines democratic processes.
"These landscapes are part of the wealth of the North," Botham stated in his commentary. "Walk through the breathtaking beauty of places like Barningham Moor and, whatever kind of day you are having, life is transformed."
The opposition also raises concerns about the economic impact, suggesting that proximity to the turbines could lead to a decrease in property values, citing academic research indicating a 12% drop for properties near turbines under 100 meters. Botham also argues that the cost of constructing and connecting these turbines, coupled with the need for backup gas power stations due to wind's intermittency, contributes to high electricity bills.
Environmental arguments against the project include potential harm to wildlife and the destruction of peatlands. Botham claims that the turbines could lead to the deaths of approximately 35,000 birds over their operational lifespan and highlights the removal of peat, a significant carbon store, for turbine foundations. He criticizes the RSPB's call for an increase in onshore turbines, suggesting it prioritizes ideology over bird protection.
Botham further criticizes the reliance on imported turbine components from countries like Denmark, Germany, and China, questioning the claim of 'homegrown energy.' He contrasts wind power unfavorably with nuclear energy, citing France's lower carbon footprint and electricity bills as an example.
The campaign also calls on several Labour Members of Parliament, including Sam Rushworth, Lola McEvoy, Joe Morris, Josh Fenton-Glynn, Anna Dixon, and Jake Richards, to oppose the plans, warning of electoral consequences if they align with party policy over constituent concerns. Botham suggests that public opposition is so strong that local Labour parties could face extinction if the proposed projects proceed under a Labour government without local MP support.