Residents of Bay Shore, New York, are voicing strong opposition to the planned opening of an all-boy Muslim boarding school, citing concerns over zoning laws and the potential impact on their residential neighborhood.
The United American Muslim Association purchased a 13-acre waterfront property on Saxon Avenue in June for $5 million. The property previously housed a Catholic seminary and later served as a residence for priests. The organization plans to establish a school that would accommodate approximately 120 teenage students, offering Islamic-centered education, early childhood programs, and community outreach.
A group of local homeowners, operating under the name "Saxon Says No," is leading the charge against the proposal. They argue that the intended use of the property for a boarding school is not in line with the existing zoning codes for the suburban neighborhood. Kevin Colgan, a leader of the group, stated that their focus is on upholding zoning integrity to preserve the character and quality of life in their community, emphasizing that their opposition is not directed at any specific group or organization.
Hundreds of residents attended a five-hour meeting of the Islip Town Zoning Board of Appeals to express their grievances. Many homeowners, like Anna Chan, who lives across the street from the proposed site, stated they relied on existing zoning protections when purchasing their homes. Concerns raised by residents include potential increases in noise levels, traffic congestion, and unanswered questions regarding a proposed accompanying daycare center.
"A boarding school with the noise that 120 teenage boys can generate in a recreational area — would you want that in your backyard?" asked Isla Belkitis, a resident living near the property.
Legal representatives for the United American Muslim Association contend that the proposal is permissible under town law. Attorney Samuel L. Bifulco stated that strict rules would be implemented to ensure students do not cause disturbances. The organization's stated goal is to provide comprehensive spiritual and academic training for its students within the community.