Lindsay Clancy's defense attorney, Kevin Reddington, expressed doubt regarding his client's ability to emotionally withstand a second trial should the current jury fail to reach a unanimous verdict. The jury in Clancy's case indicated on Tuesday that they were deadlocked after days of deliberation. A judge instructed the jurors to continue their discussions.
"She had a flat affect, she's sad," Reddington told reporters outside the courthouse, describing Clancy's demeanor during the deliberations. When asked if Clancy could emotionally handle a retrial, Reddington responded with a definitive "No."
The trial could potentially result in a mistrial and necessitate a new court proceeding if the jury remains divided. Reddington suggested that if Plymouth District Attorney Timothy Cruz were to reduce the charges to second-degree murder, Clancy might opt for a bench trial, which typically involves a judge rather than a jury and can be a less public process.
"You should ask Mr. Cruz why we are trying on triple homicide first degree, not me," Reddington stated when questioned about the possibility of a retrial on the most severe charges. Clancy's parents and sister were also present leaving the court as the jury was sent home for the day.