Andy Burnham, the Prime Minister, has stated that he is not ruling out a reversal of Labour's 'jobs tax' for young workers, following criticism from his own adviser that party policies have fueled youth joblessness. Alan Milburn, a former minister and key adviser, acknowledged in a report that measures such as increased National Insurance contributions (NICs) for employers and a higher minimum wage for younger workers have negatively impacted business sentiment.
Milburn's report, which addresses Britain's one million young people not in education, employment, or training (NEETs), proposes significant immediate investment in work support, coupled with welfare cuts for those who do not cooperate. The report suggests that policies implemented since Labour took office, including raising employer NICs and increasing the minimum wage for younger staff at a faster rate than for older employees, have made hiring young workers more expensive.
Milburn recommended doubling the NICs threshold for businesses employing under-25s from £5,000 to £10,000, initially in the retail and hospitality sectors. He noted that during her tenure as Chancellor, Rachel Reeves raised the headline NICs rate while simultaneously slashing the earnings threshold from £9,100 to £5,000, bringing many part-time jobs into the tax system.
When questioned about potentially reversing these NICs measures, Burnham indicated that the government would consider the entire report. "We're not ruling anything out at this point in time. We'll look at everything in the round," he stated.
The government has accepted several recommendations from Milburn's report, including legislation for an 'opportunity and support guarantee' for young people and an extension of a scheme offering fully-funded six-month jobs to jobless youngsters on benefits for a year. A new 'youth opportunities unit,' chaired by Milburn, will also be established.
However, the Work and Pensions Secretary, Pat McFadden, avoided confirming whether the government would adopt Milburn's call to cut NICs for firms employing young people, stating that tax policy is a matter for Chancellor John Healey. The Conservative Party criticized Labour's proposals, with Shadow Work and Pensions Secretary Helen Whately arguing that the review exposed the flaws in the government's economic policies and demanding the scrapping of the 'jobs tax.'
Milburn's report warns that without substantial reforms, the NEETs rate could reach 1.27 million in five years. The proposed measures, including a new benefits system for young people and potential cuts to NICs, are projected to reduce the NEET rate to 6.8% by 2036. The report acknowledges that savings from these reforms will not be realized for at least a decade, with initial funding requirements in the billions.
Milburn defended the proposal to reduce benefits for young people who refuse guaranteed work or training, stating, "In the end, for the vast majority of young people, work beats welfare every single time." He cautioned against implementing drastic benefit cuts without accompanying support, warning of increased destitution and costs shifted to other public services.
The report also highlights the challenge for young people in securing entry-level positions, with youth employment rates falling and entry-level vacancies decreasing significantly over the past decade. Milburn's recommendations include slowing the increase of the youth minimum wage and pausing elements of the Employment Rights Act.
Amidst ongoing speculation about a potential May election, government policy based on Milburn's review is expected in the new year, with legislation anticipated by mid-next year. Some Labour MPs have expressed concerns about welfare reforms, citing past rebellions against similar measures. However, others have voiced support for Milburn's report. The report emphasizes the need for significant investment, stating, "There is no honest version of change in which the country declares youth participation a national priority and then refuses to pay for making it real."