Karmelo Anthony Defense Seeks Judge's Recusal Over Post-Trial Comments

The defense team for Karmelo Anthony, who was convicted in June of murdering 17-year-old Austin Metcalf, has asked a judge to remove presiding Judge John Roach from all remaining proceedings. The request stems from public comments Roach made after the trial, which the defense argues created an appearance of bias.

A recusal hearing is scheduled for Wednesday, with Judge Sid Harle set to preside. Anthony is expected to attend the hearing. A bench warrant had been issued in the case, according to a Collin County official.

Anthony's legal team, led by Attorney Russell Wilson II, filed a motion to recuse Roach on July 7. The filing cites comments in which Roach stated the jury "got it right" and defended certain trial rulings, including his management of courtroom access and the dismissal of three Black prospective jurors. The defense contends these remarks indicate Roach may have prejudged the defense's post-trial claims.

Karmelo Anthony was sentenced to 35 years in prison for fatally stabbing Austin Metcalf during an altercation at a Frisco track meet.

The defense's motion does not directly contest Anthony's guilt or innocence but instead alleges constitutional and legal errors that they claim deprived him of a fair trial. Specifically, the filing challenges the court's limited public access, noting that cameras were barred from the courtroom and only 27 seats were available for the public. Attorneys also accuse prosecutors of violating an off-the-record agreement regarding character evidence, which they argue may have improperly influenced Anthony's decision on whether to testify.

Additionally, the defense is challenging the jury instructions, asserting they limited the jurors' ability to fully consider Anthony's claim of self-defense.

Separately, a hearing on Anthony's request for a new trial is scheduled for Thursday. Roach referred the recusal request to another judge, as per Texas procedure. The outcome of Wednesday's hearing could impact who handles Anthony's motion for a new trial and other post-conviction matters in the trial court.