A federal judge has declined to release from custody a man who was shot and wounded by U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) agents during his arrest in New York last month. U.S. District Court Judge Hector Gonzalez stated in a written ruling that while agents may have made a procedural error in serving an arrest warrant on Oscar Belgal before he received a notice to appear in immigration court, this technical error does not necessitate his release.

Belgal, a 28-year-old Dominican national, entered the U.S. illegally in 2021. He was arrested on robbery and other charges approximately two years later, eventually pleading guilty to grand larceny and receiving a sentence of probation. In 2025, he was arrested again on allegations of attempting to sell controlled substances, a case that is still pending.

On October 8, ICE agents apprehended Belgal as he was driving his 5-year-old son home from school. Security camera footage released by the New York City Police Department shows an officer approaching Belgal's car with a gun drawn, then using the firearm's barrel to break the driver's side window. A second officer drew his weapon as Belgal began to drive away. The pursuit concluded shortly after, with Belgal's car coming to a stop after being struck by gunfire.

Belgal sustained injuries to his shoulder and neck, but his son was unharmed. His attorneys, from The Legal Aid Society, stated that he was unaware the individuals were ICE officers until he woke up in the hospital. The organization issued a statement calling his continued detention "unconscionable," especially given his suffering and separation from his family.

Federal officials asserted that ICE officers fired their weapons because they believed their lives were in danger, alleging that Belgal crashed his car into two government vehicles and accelerated toward other officers.

Belgal's attorneys argued that the agents lacked a valid warrant and did not identify themselves before smashing the car window and firing shots. They also contended that Belgal's due process rights were violated due to the "unreasonable use of extreme force" during his arrest. Judge Gonzalez disagreed with the claim that the agents did not have a valid warrant and determined that the petition for release was not the appropriate venue to argue excessive force.

The judge noted that Belgal has the option to seek release on bond through the immigration court. Belgal's case occurred amid increased immigration enforcement efforts.