Jamie Vardy has been named the greatest signing in Premier League history, surpassing legendary figures like Eric Cantona and Vincent Kompany. This assessment is based on his transformative impact, legacy, and unparalleled value, particularly in leading Leicester City to their historic Premier League title win in 2016.
While Leicester City was in the Championship when they signed Vardy for £1 million from Fleetwood in May 2012, his contribution to the club's improbable rise and subsequent title victory is considered unmatched. His 24 goals during the 2015-2016 season were fundamental to Leicester's counter-attacking style under manager Claudio Ranieri. Vardy's presence not only terrified opponents but also dictated their tactical approaches, cementing his role as the figurehead of what is widely regarded as the greatest Premier League story.
The debate for the greatest signing often includes Eric Cantona, whose £1.2 million transfer from Leeds to Manchester United in November 1992 is lauded for its audacity. Cantona is credited with galvanizing Manchester United, helping them end a 26-year title drought and secure three more titles in the subsequent four years. However, the argument against Cantona being the absolute greatest is that Manchester United possessed a strong squad and likely would have achieved success even without him.
Vincent Kompany's £6 million move to Manchester City from Hamburg in 2008 is highlighted as an example of exceptional value. Other notable signings for their impact and financial return include Philippe Coutinho, who joined Liverpool for £8.5 million and was later sold for £142 million, significantly bolstering Liverpool's squad. Andy Robertson, a key part of Liverpool's success, cost a modest £8 million.
Other players mentioned in discussions of great value or impact include Ole Gunnar Solskjaer (£1.5 million to Manchester United), Seamus Coleman (£60,000 to Everton for his long-term service), Nicolas Anelka (£500,000 to Arsenal), Patrick Vieira (£3.5 million to Arsenal), and Cesar Azpilicueta (to Chelsea from Marseille). While these players contributed to numerous trophies, Vardy's role in Leicester's singular Premier League title win is seen as redefining the possibilities within the league.