An HR director at Jaguar Land Rover had his £4 million discrimination case dismissed after the intense and 'adversarial' nature of courtroom questioning left him too ill to continue. James Baker, who had lodged a wide array of claims including disability discrimination, alleging bullying and harassment, had his case adjourned multiple times due to severe health reactions.
Health Impacts During Testimony
Following his first day of cross-examination in June, Mr. Baker's blood pressure spiked, leading to an adjournment. A subsequent psychiatric evaluation indicated that Mr. Baker was suffering from intense anxiety, and the adversarial approach in the hearing had triggered adrenaline responses that resulted in elevated blood pressure. The psychiatrist noted that this style of questioning induced intense symptoms of PTSD and suggested providing Mr. Baker with advance notice of cross-examination topics to mitigate these effects.
When the hearing resumed in September, Mr. Baker reportedly failed to utilize the medically recommended adjustments. After another day of cross-examination, his blood pressure spiked again, necessitating hospital treatment. The tribunal had previously agreed to allow Mr. Baker, who was the Head of HR, Overseas, for JLR, to take ten-minute breaks every half hour while giving evidence.
Legal Proceedings and Dismissal
Medical evidence presented suggested a 'chicken and egg' scenario where Mr. Baker's mental health would not improve until the dispute was resolved. Jaguar Land Rover argued that Mr. Baker's medical condition had worsened significantly since June, and any further adjournment would infringe upon their right to a fair trial due to the potential loss of evidence cogency.
Mr. Baker's legal team proposed that JLR provide a list of written questions or that he be allowed to respond in writing. However, the judge concluded that requiring JLR to provide its cross-examination questions in advance constituted a fundamental interference with the company's right to a fair trial, deeming it unreasonable and disproportionate.
Employment Judge Hilary Harding granted JLR's application to strike out the case midway through the tribunal, stating that a fair trial was no longer possible. Mr. Baker had sought compensation exceeding £4 million, with claims encompassing direct disability discrimination, discrimination arising from disability, failure to make reasonable adjustments, harassment related to disability, whistleblowing detriment, victimisation, automatically unfair dismissal, ordinary unfair dismissal, and breach of contract.
Mr. Baker claimed to suffer from chronic pain, PTSD, anxiety, and depression, which Jaguar Land Rover contested. His claims referenced a history of bullying and harassment, including incidents that led to hospitalizations in 2018 and 2019. He alleged unlawful, unfair, and detrimental treatment as the primary causes of his sickness absence and mental ill-health. Specific allegations included a failure by JLR to make reasonable adjustments following an occupational health report in January 2021, a herniated disc allegedly caused by working 14-hour days during the COVID-19 pandemic, a panic attack triggered by a colleague calling him while on holiday in July 2022, and considerable stress due to a work colleague undermining his role in 2023.
Mr. Baker went on sick leave in September 2023 and did not return before resigning in May 2025. The triggers for his anxiety and PTSD were identified as exposure to situations reminding him of alleged 'index incidents' at work, and the tribunal process itself, particularly the style of questioning. The judgment noted that while a psychiatrist differentiated between hostile treatment and adversarial questioning, Mr. Baker perceived the latter as hostile.
Judge Harding ultimately determined that, considering the time already lost and the time required for ongoing applications, a fair trial was no longer feasible within the allocated trial period.