The third episode of HBO's 'Lanterns,' titled "OutKast," has been met with criticism for perceived creative stumbles, including a convoluted origin story and character relationships that strain credulity. The episode delves into the past of John Stewart, exploring the origins of his fearlessness and his intertwined history with Hal Jordan.
John Stewart's Origin Story
The narrative reveals that John Stewart's father, John Sr., was denied the Green Lantern mantle because he admitted to fear when questioned by the ring. This led to a descent into alcoholism and resentment. A Guardian of the Universe, appearing in human form, later offers John Sr.'s wife, Bernadette, compensation for their suffering and hints that their son, John Jr., could be a candidate for Green Lantern if he can overcome fear. Bernadette then dedicates herself to training young John to be fearless, involving him in dangerous exercises, including shooting an apple off his mother's head.
Hal Jordan's Impact on Stewart's Career
The episode also details how Hal Jordan's actions directly impacted John Stewart's life and career. During a black ops mission where Stewart, a Marine sniper, was in position for nine months, Jordan intervened, leading to Stewart's dishonorable discharge. This event was concealed to protect Jordan's involvement in foreign policy. Later, despite Stewart's military background, his mother enrolls him in art school, a path whose relevance to his future is unclear. It is after this that Stewart is finally approached by the Guardians.
Evolving Character Dynamics
The relationship between Stewart and Jordan is further complicated by the Guardians' interest in Stewart as a potential replacement for Jordan. This adds a layer of paranoia to Jordan's already strained relationship with his protégé. Critics note that while the episode introduces elements like Sinestro's backstory and Hal Jordan's past mentorship, the heavy emphasis on Hal Jordan as the source of John Stewart's problems, from his childhood trauma to his career's end, has drawn particular attention. The episode's attempt to portray Stewart as a potential "wolf in sheep's clothing" is seen as an effort to add depth to his character, but some critics worry that the accumulated baggage may weigh down the series' potential.