Former New York City Mayor Rudy Giuliani has called on Mayor Zohran Mamdani to abstain from the upcoming 9/11 memorial ceremonies, stating that the prospect of his attendance is offensive. Giuliani, who led the city in the aftermath of the 2001 terror attacks, expressed his sentiments on Newsmax Sunday, arguing that the ceremony is for victims' families and national remembrance.
Giuliani, who lost friends in the attacks, claimed Mamdani does not believe 9/11 was an Islamic terrorist attack and suggested the mayor is part of a global Islamic plot. He further alleged that Mamdani, a practicing Muslim, conceals his alleged anti-American views, contrasting him with Osama bin Laden, who was openly hostile to the U.S.
Giuliani's demand has been echoed by other prominent figures, including former New York Gov. George Pataki and Republican gubernatorial candidate Bruce Blakeman. Pataki stated that anyone not distancing themselves from individuals who have blamed U.S. foreign policy for the attacks or called for violence against Jews should not attend. Blakeman cited similar concerns regarding Mamdani's associations.
These calls stem from Mamdani's connections with controversial figures, including a far-left influencer who previously commented that "America deserved 9/11." While both Mamdani and the influencer have rejected the past comment, Mamdani has continued to associate with him. Pataki suggested Mamdani either reject these views or voluntarily decide not to attend the memorial.
However, New York Gov. Kathy Hochul countered these calls, asserting that Mamdani absolutely should attend as the current mayor of New York City. Hochul argued that Mamdani's absence would be a significant insult to the majority of victims' families who do not oppose his attendance. She emphasized the importance of communal unity in opposing terrorism and standing with first responders and families who lost loved ones.
Mamdani has indicated no intention to alter his schedule, reaffirming his commitment to attend the memorial. His office released a statement expressing pride in honoring the families, survivors, and first responders and reaffirming a commitment to never forget the day's impact on the city and country.