Duncan Campbell, former head of content at ARN, stated that he knew The Kyle and Jackie O Show was destined for trouble just ten minutes into its Melbourne broadcast in 2024. Campbell shared this insight on the Game Changers Radio podcast, explaining that the hosts, Kyle Sandilands and Jackie Henderson, were instructed to tone down their characteristic sexual and outlandish content for the Melbourne demographic.

"Probably 10 minutes into the first show (I knew)," Campbell said. He had spoken with Sandilands prior to the broadcast, who had agreed to exercise restraint. However, Campbell observed a significant shift between their Friday conversation and the Monday show, leading him to believe the program would "go to a whole other level now."

Campbell indicated that he foresaw growing issues with the show well before the widely reported on-air clash between Sandilands and Henderson in March, which ultimately led to the show's cancellation. The dispute reportedly centered on Henderson's "fixation" on astrology.

Following the cancellation, high-profile legal battles have ensued between the duo and their former employer, ARN. Sandilands, 55, settled with ARN for $12.09 million, reportedly close to a year's salary under his contract, which included a multimillion-dollar base fee, a $1 million sign-on bonus, and a $3 million one-off fee. This settlement also included $1.5 million in advertising contra.

Meanwhile, Henderson, 51, is pursuing a Fair Work claim against ARN over her $100 million contract. A court date has been set for October 12 for her legal dispute, with an interlocutory hearing scheduled for August 24. Henderson launched her claim in April, alleging ARN failed to provide a safe workplace and minimize psychosocial risks after she lodged multiple complaints against Sandilands. Her legal team has confirmed they will continue with the case, even after Sandilands' settlement. Insiders suggest Henderson could receive less than Sandilands if she settles, with her bid for an $82 million payout facing renewed scrutiny.

Court documents indicate that Henderson may be required to undergo a medical examination, to be conducted by an expert selected by ARN. ARN is then obligated to file an affidavit from their chosen expert on August 6. Henderson's former employer stated that the examination is to determine her condition as part of the legal action.