A federal judge appointed by former President George W. Bush has blocked a Trump administration immigration rule that would have placed new restrictions on visas for international students and exchange visitors. District Judge F. Dennis Saylor IV of Massachusetts ruled that the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) exceeded its authority by promulgating the rule, which would have replaced the previous policy of allowing international students to study in the U.S. for indefinite periods as long as they remained enrolled and maintained legal status.
The rule, which was challenged by labor unions and university presidents, would have imposed fixed timeframes for study, generally capped at four years, with extensions requiring new applications. It also included new restrictions on transferring schools, changing academic programs, and pursuing additional degrees, alongside increased immigration reviews to combat fraud and national security threats.
Judge Saylor stated that the DHS rule was not reasonably related to the F-1 visa program's purpose and that the agency did not adequately explain how the new system would improve upon existing methods for catching visa fraud. He argued that the agency was seeking to undermine a program that Congress intended to permit and encourage. The judge had previously blocked the rule in September, but his latest ruling struck it down entirely, finding that DHS violated federal administrative law.
The DHS had argued that indefinite admission periods prevented immigration officials from periodically reassessing visa compliance and that mandatory extensions would create opportunities to identify fraud and security risks. However, Saylor questioned how a four-year limit would meaningfully enhance the ability to root out fraud compared to the existing system, which relies on the Student and Exchange Visitor Information System (SEVIS) for monitoring.
The White House has indicated plans to appeal the decision.