The Television Academy's decision to consolidate Outstanding Scripted Variety Series and Outstanding Talk Series into a new Best Variety Series category could result in as many as five winners this year. The change, announced in January due to a "reduced number of submissions," redefines the category as an "area award," where nominees do not compete against each other but are judged individually.
Under the new system, voters will be asked a yes-or-no question for each of the five nominated series: "Does this nominee merit an Emmy?" Any nominee receiving 90% or more "yes" votes will be awarded an Emmy. If no nominee reaches this threshold, the one with the highest percentage of "yes" votes will win.
This format has drawn criticism, with one awards insider describing it as "stupid" and feeling like a "participation trophy," as it shifts the focus from selecting one winner to individually approving each nominee. "Because you’re not just picking one, you are actively voting against something by saying, ‘No, they don’t deserve this,’" the insider commented.
Despite the potential for multiple wins, clearing the 90% bar remains a significant challenge. "Last Week Tonight with John Oliver" appears to be a strong contender, having secured the top prize for the past decade.
"The Late Show with Stephen Colbert" is also considered a likely winner. With the show having aired its final episode in May, this awards ceremony presents a final opportunity for voters to honor the longtime host.
Jimmy Kimmel's show could also garner support, particularly given recent controversies that led to his brief off-air suspension. The submitted episode for his nomination is noted to be from his first day back after the incident.
"The Daily Show" and "Saturday Night Live" are also nominated. Their chances may depend on how selectively voters decide to distribute their "yes" votes, potentially impacting the perceived integrity of the awards if too many winners are produced.