Dwayne Johnson’s ‘Moana’ Remake Underwhelms, Critics Say

The live-action remake of Disney's animated film "Moana" has arrived on Disney+ a decade after the original and less than two years after its animated sequel, "Moana 2." However, the new adaptation is facing criticism for its perceived lack of originality and its underwhelming box office performance, grossing $323 million worldwide against a production budget exceeding $250 million.

Critics point to the film's release strategy, noting that "Moana 2" already offered a continuation of the original story. This live-action version, directed by Thomas Kail, is described as largely mirroring the plot of the 2016 animated film. The story follows Moana, played by Catherine Laga’aia, as she embarks on a journey to find the demigod Maui, voiced by Dwayne Johnson, to restore the heart of Te Fiti and save her island.

Performance and Production Concerns

Dwayne Johnson reprises his role as Maui, appearing in a costume that includes a prosthetic bodysuit, which some reviewers found to be an unnecessary addition given Johnson's own physique. The film's visual effects and green-screen work have also drawn criticism, with reviewers noting their artificiality. Laga’aia delivers a performance described as warm and upbeat, but her chemistry with Johnson is seen as lacking. The musical numbers, including "You're Welcome" and "How Far I'll Go," are reported to feel lifeless and mechanical.

Reviewers have compared "Moana" to other recent Disney live-action remakes such as "The Little Mermaid," "Pinocchio," and "Snow White," many of which have also been met with mixed to negative reception. While some remakes like "Mufasa" and "Lilo and Stitch" were considered artistically acceptable, and others like "Mulan" and "Peter Pan and Wendy" were seen as justifying their existence, "Moana" is largely viewed as a disappointing entry in this trend.

Artistic and Business Decisions

The artistic reasoning behind the remake has been questioned, with critics suggesting it is primarily a business decision aimed at exploiting existing intellectual property. The film's director, a veteran of Broadway productions like "Hamilton" and "In the Heights," is noted for failing to bring significant innovation to the adaptation. This perceived creative bankruptcy and the film's cynical origins are highlighted as reasons for its listless execution.

Despite the criticisms, the enduring nature of the "Moana" story itself is acknowledged. However, reviewers ultimately recommend skipping the remake and revisiting the original animated film. The film is now available on Disney+.