Dodgers' Handling of Shohei Ohtani's Struggles Draws Scrutiny

The Los Angeles Dodgers have faced criticism for their decision to keep Shohei Ohtani in the lineup for Game 3 of the National League Championship Series, despite his apparent physical struggles and a prolonged offensive slump. The team's explanations for this choice have been met with skepticism, particularly as they trail the Milwaukee Brewers two games to none.

While Ohtani himself expressed a desire to play, the Dodgers' public statements have suggested he is on the verge of an offensive breakthrough. Manager Dave Roberts indicated that Ohtani felt "close to finding something" mechanically. However, Ohtani has not hit a home run since August 18, and his only hits in the current postseason have been singles. The team's decision to continue playing him as the designated hitter, rather than giving an opportunity to promising prospect Josue De Paula, has fueled debate.

Ohtani's performance in Game 2 of the NLCS marked one of his worst outings of the playoffs, going hitless with two strikeouts where he appeared overmatched. Despite reaching base in previous games, his overall effectiveness has been noticeably diminished. The Dodgers' decision to keep him in the lineup is seen by some as a choice born out of necessity rather than confidence in his current form, given that their other potential replacements, like De Paula, are unproven at this high level of competition.

The argument that De Paula, a highly touted prospect, would not significantly improve the Dodgers' chances against playoff-caliber pitching is acknowledged. However, the team's explanations for Ohtani's continued presence have been questioned, especially since Roberts had previously suggested he might consider removing Ohtani from the lineup. Reports indicate Ohtani has been dealing with discomfort in his right arm, left knee, and right hip. Roberts himself has alluded to Ohtani dealing with "everything" including "the upper body. It's the knee."

The Dodgers' strategy in this crucial series is under the microscope, with their explanations for relying on a physically compromised star drawing particular attention as they attempt to overcome a deficit against the Brewers.