Dodgers Face Ohtani Dilemma as Age and Injury Cloud Future

The Los Angeles Dodgers face a significant offseason challenge in determining how to manage Shohei Ohtani's future as a two-way player. Ohtani, who turns 33 next season, was unable to complete a full season performing both as a pitcher and a hitter, leading to concerns about his long-term capacity for such a demanding role.

Dodgers president of baseball operations Andrew Friedman acknowledged the uncertainty surrounding Ohtani's ability to continue as a two-way player for an entire season. When asked if Ohtani could have been healthier for the playoffs had he been managed differently earlier in the season, Friedman stated, "I don't know the answer to that." Similarly, when questioned about the possibility of Ohtani playing both ways for a full season at his age, Friedman responded, "I don't know the answer to that."

These responses have raised concerns among observers, suggesting a potential disconnect between the team's reality and its strategic planning. The Dodgers must engage in a candid discussion with Ohtani about managing his workload to prevent a recurrence of his compromised physical state during crucial playoff games. His performance in the recent postseason was significantly impacted by lingering knee and arm injuries, batting just .192 with 10 strikeouts in 32 plate appearances and hitting his only playoff home run on the day the Dodgers were eliminated.

Friedman indicated that the team's braintrust would collaborate with Ohtani to develop a plan for improved health in the playoffs. He highlighted Ohtani's "team-first mentality" and his willingness to do "whatever it takes to help the team win." However, Ohtani himself has expressed an intention to "do everything" next season, potentially creating a conflict if he insists on a workload similar to what he had earlier this year.

The team's approach this past season, which appeared to prioritize Ohtani's desires over practical considerations, has led to questions about power dynamics within the organization. Friedman's reluctance to directly address Ohtani's limitations has fueled this perception. The Dodgers must now determine if they can assertively guide Ohtani toward a more sustainable role, even if it means limiting his two-way duties, especially considering he is no longer in his twenties.

Friedman hinted at potential adjustments, such as delaying the start of Ohtani's pitching season or carefully managing his workload in the initial month. The key challenge for the Dodgers will be to communicate their concerns effectively to Ohtani, emphasizing what is best for both the team and his personal well-being. The success of this endeavor hinges on the Dodgers' ability to provide Ohtani with a clear and honest assessment of his current physical limitations, guiding him toward a more realistic approach to his unique skillset.