The New York City chapter of the Democratic Socialists of America (DSA) recently hosted a workshop focused on critiquing the U.S. Constitution, with some participants describing it as "a rationalization of a pirate kingdom." The event, held at the DSA's Lower East Side headquarters, brainstormed ways to potentially abolish foundational elements of the U.S. government.
Boston College Law Professor Aziz Rana, a featured speaker at the workshop, argued that the Constitution is moving towards an authoritarian system and is incompatible with democratic change. He told attendees that the document contains "deep undemocratic elements" and empowers the state to engage in "various forms of violence." Rana also suggested that the rights established by the Constitution often favor property holders.
Rana, author of "The Constitutional Bind: How Americans Came to Idolize a Document that Fails Them," is a frequent speaker at DSA events. His book is described by the DSA as a "blueprint for the left to return to agitating."
During the workshop, attendees discussed the potential abolition of institutions such as the U.S. Senate, Supreme Court, Electoral College, and the presidency. One participant expressed a desire for automatic voting rights for all individuals over 18 who possess the mental capacity to vote, suggesting that voter registration should be abolished.
Another attendee commented on the need to "take care of each other in a different way" than what they characterized as a "WASP mentality" that permits exploitation. The workshop was reportedly catered with a lunch that included various kebabs, labneh, and zaatar bread.
The DSA's workshop invite stated that "it has become increasingly apparent that the US Constitution exacerbates some of the worst elements of American politics." The organization recently implemented a new requirement for endorsed candidates to support their "full radical agenda."
Critics have voiced concerns about these discussions, with one former U.S. ambassador to the European Union stating that elements like the Senate, Electoral College, and separation of powers were intentional features of the Constitution designed to protect against the potential dangers of unchecked majorities. He added that "Every generation thinks it's smarter than Madison until it finds itself in the political minority."