Longtime Democratic strategist Al Hunt has sharply criticized the Democratic National Committee's recent embrace of the "abolish ICE" slogan, describing it as a "dumb" idea with significant political ramifications.

"That’s insanity on two grounds. As policy, how can a nation exist without an immigration agency, and politically, it’s a gift to troubled Republicans," Hunt stated on the podcast "Politics War Room." He likened the slogan to the "stupidest idea since Democrats called for abolishing the police."

The Democratic National Committee approved two policy positions on immigration enforcement, one advocating for "concrete reforms" and the other for the outright abolition of Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE).

Hunt expressed concerns that the "abolish ICE" stance could be exploited by Republicans, who might use it to suggest Democrats favor open borders. He acknowledged that the current iteration of ICE, which he believes takes orders from Stephen Miller, is "out of control" and contains "too many ill-trained thugs who have injured and even murdered innocent people."

However, he argued for a complete overhaul and reform of the agency under a new administration, rather than abolition. "It needs to be reformed. Throw out all the current leaders. Bring in serious law enforcement and immigration experts. Set rigorous training standards, rules and accountability," Hunt proposed.

His co-host, James Carville, agreed with Hunt's assessment, emphasizing that the primary goal for DNC members should be winning elections. "It’s not your job to steer the policy direction of the party. It’s your job to win elections," Carville said.

Recent polling data suggests a complex public sentiment regarding ICE. A March poll by Economist/YouGov indicated that half of Americans surveyed somewhat or strongly support abolishing ICE, following controversies surrounding the agency's actions. These controversies include instances of alleged excessive force by federal agents during immigration crackdowns under the Trump administration, which led to the brief detention of U.S. citizens and the deaths of two individuals.

Furthermore, a February Marist survey found that 65% of Americans believe ICE's enforcement actions have gone too far.