Attorneys for Tyler Robinson, accused of assassinating conservative commentator Charlie Kirk, are requesting a Utah judge pause additional ballistics testing on bullet fragments recovered from Kirk's autopsy. The defense argues that further testing could alter or damage the evidence, potentially compromising their ability to independently examine and present it at trial.
Prosecutors are seeking to use virtual comparison microscopy (VCM) to definitively link bullet fragments found during the autopsy to the suspected murder weapon, a .30-06 Mauser rifle. While prosecutors acknowledge this testing is not central to their case, they contend it will not destroy the evidence and that defense experts will have an opportunity to review it. Deputy Utah County Attorney Ryan McBride stated that the fragments are expected to contain inculpatory evidence and that Robinson has allegedly admitted to the shooting.
Robinson's legal team contends that prior testing by the ATF has already altered the fragments, and further analysis by the FBI could lead to irreversible changes. They are seeking to either examine the evidence before the FBI test or have a defense expert observe the process. The FBI typically does not allow such observation due to concerns over contamination and national security.
Former ATF special agent Bernard Zapor suggested that concerns about evidence damage might be overstated, noting that the fragments were already meticulously documented. He added that if the fragments are damaged further, it might not significantly impact the case, as the initial testing was inconclusive. Jason Pack, a retired FBI supervisory agent, commented that VCM is a more advanced process than traditional microscopy, but conclusive results are not guaranteed if markings are already damaged.
Robinson is accused of shooting Kirk on September 10, 2025, during a Turning Point USA event at Utah Valley University. Investigators recovered a bullet jacket fragment and four lead fragments from Kirk's body. Previous ATF testing identified the fragment as being in the .30 caliber class but could not conclusively link it to Robinson's grandfather's rifle. Prosecutors are also seeking metallurgical testing and analysis of unfired cartridges found in Robinson's home. Robinson has pleaded not guilty to all charges and could face the death penalty if convicted of aggravated murder.