Crystal Palace has offloaded Brennan Johnson, their second-most expensive signing, to Everton in a swap deal that sees Dwight McNeil move to Selhurst Park. Johnson, who joined Palace in January for a club-record £35 million, has been transferred for no cash, with McNeil valued at £15 million. The deal effectively represents a £20 million loss for Palace just seven months after Johnson's arrival.
This transaction highlights Palace's acknowledgment of overspending on Johnson. His departure also frees up significant salary funds, as Johnson was reportedly earning £125,000 per week, considerably more than McNeil's understood wages.
Performance and Tactical Fit Issues
Despite initial optimism, Johnson struggled to make an impact at Crystal Palace. His tenure was marked by a goalless streak in 26 appearances, a stark contrast to his previous success at Tottenham Hotspur, where he scored 18 goals and was a key player. A difficult half-season at Spurs, following the exit of manager Ange Postecoglou, reportedly impacted his confidence.
Sources indicate that Johnson's incompatibility with Palace's tactical setup was a primary issue. As an out-and-out winger who thrives on wide runs, he was often played in a narrow, No. 10 role, a position where he lacked experience and opportunity to showcase his strengths. Manager Oliver Glasner noted in March that Johnson seemed to put too much pressure on himself, hindering his ability to play with freedom.
Johnson's confidence appeared to further erode after missing a crucial penalty for Wales in a World Cup qualification play-off. His performances on the pitch lacked conviction, with statistics showing low engagement in the opposition box and a high number of possession losses per 90 minutes. While his teammates reportedly saw potential in training and believed he needed reassurance, club hierarchy members grew concerned about the substantial investment.
The Swap Deal Dynamics
By the summer, Palace determined Johnson was not the right fit and sought to cut their losses. Johnson also expressed a desire for a new challenge, creating an opening for Everton, who had previously shown interest in January. Everton manager David Moyes, a long-time admirer of Johnson, pursued him even when managing West Ham.
The terms of the swap deal were described as generous by Everton. The agreement was facilitated by both clubs accepting the move and the players sharing the same agency, Unique Sports Group. Everton faces minimal risk beyond Johnson's wages, acquiring a player with a proven goal-scoring and assisting record, aside from his Palace spell. Moyes has a history of revitalizing players who have experienced difficult periods, and he is expected to work with Johnson on recapturing his earlier form.
Palace's decision to sell McNeil, who had one year left on his contract, was made with the knowledge they were prepared to part with him. Johnson's move to Everton, where he is expected to return to a more familiar right-wing role, will see him face his former club on the opening day of the Premier League season.