Critics Accuse Left of Spreading 'Big Lies' About Israel

Recent actions by some on the left, including attempts to halt U.S. weapons sales to Israel, are being characterized as spreading "Big Lies" with harmful consequences. Critics argue that these accusations, such as claims of genocide or indiscriminate use of American-supplied munitions in Gaza and Lebanon, are unfounded and ignore Israel's efforts to minimize civilian casualties.

Representative Gregory Meeks attempted to place a hold on a $2.8 billion sale of U.S. bombs to Israel, citing concerns about their potential use in densely populated areas. He stated that the sale raises "grave, unresolved concerns." However, critics contend that these weapons are necessary for Israel to address underground tunnels and bunkers used by groups like Hamas and Hezbollah. Meeks has maintained support for Israel's right to self-defense.

Similarly, Representative Pramila Jayapal has opposed the weapons sale, alleging that U.S. weapons are being used to "perpetrate a genocide." This assertion is disputed by critics who maintain that Israel does not use bombs indiscriminately and avoids striking areas where high civilian casualties are anticipated.

These claims are further linked to a new film, "NAZA," which reportedly suggests the Israeli Defense Forces (IDF) use artificial intelligence to identify targets in Gaza, leading to civilian deaths. Critics refute this, stating that the IDF does not delegate targeting decisions to AI and would not proceed with strikes if a high civilian casualty rate was expected.

Instead, the argument is made that Israel employs extensive measures to prevent civilian harm, more so than any military in history, according to urban warfare expert John Spencer. These measures include aborting strikes, diverting missiles mid-flight, providing advance warnings to civilians via phone and leaflets, and utilizing pinpoint targeting. The IDF has also reportedly risked soldiers' lives to protect civilians from Hamas and has opted for ground operations over airstrikes to reduce civilian risk, despite the increased danger to its own troops.

The accusation of genocide is leveled by numerous figures, including Mayor Zohran Mamdani, Representative Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, Brad Lander, and Representative Rashida Tlaib. Critics point to the fact that Gaza's population has grown significantly over the past two decades, even during periods of conflict, as evidence against the genocide claim. They also note that Israel has provided aid, such as food and medicine, to the region.

The term "Big Lie," originally defined by Adolf Hitler as a fabrication so outlandish that people would believe it, is now being applied by critics to what they see as the anti-Israel propaganda campaign. They argue that the distortion of truth is being used on a global scale against Israel.