California Father of Triplets Murdered in Suspected Mistaken Identity Case
Authorities believe Avtar Singh was targeted due to a stolen trailer, not for personal reasons.
A California father of newborn triplets was kidnapped and murdered in what authorities now believe was a case of mistaken identity. Avtar Singh, 57, disappeared in February from a Sikh temple in Tracy, approximately 60 miles east of San Francisco. His body was discovered days later in a remote area of Lake Berryessa in Napa Valley.
Investigators with the San Joaquin County Sheriff's Office have identified three men suspected in connection with Singh's death: Alberto Alencastro, 25, Alfonso Segura, 20, and Barnabe Segura, 22. All three suspects, who are from Vallejo, remain at large. They have been indicted on charges including murder with special circumstances and kidnapping.
Surveillance footage showed Singh being abducted by three individuals in a white SUV. The suspect vehicle was identified using Flock license plate readers and subsequently seized on February 19, according to the sheriff's office.
Police stated that Singh was not the intended target of the kidnapping and was mistaken for someone else. Approximately one week after seizing the vehicle, investigators traveled to Canada to interview the individual believed to be the intended target. This individual and his family had reportedly been receiving threats related to a stolen trailer, which investigators believe motivated the suspects.
Singh resided on the grounds of a Sikh temple in Tracy with his wife and children. San Joaquin County Sheriff Patrick Withrow assured Singh's widow that the office would pursue the individuals responsible.
The three suspects face potential life sentences without the possibility of parole. The Sikh community had offered a $50,000 cash reward for information leading to their arrest.
Singh's family established a fundraiser to assist with funeral expenses and provide financial stability for his wife and children. Singh had reportedly served the temple for over 20 years and was described by his family as known for his humility, quiet dedication, and a loving nature that made others feel like family. His service, sincerity, and faith profoundly impacted the community, and his absence is deeply felt.