Orange County District Attorney Todd Spitzer has filed a legal challenge against Governor Gavin Newsom's decision to commute the death sentences of 18 inmates, arguing that the governor overstepped his authority by not requiring further judicial review for those without prior felony convictions.

The challenge specifically targets inmates whose death sentences were commuted without automatic review by the California Supreme Court, a process that typically applies to those with prior felony convictions. Spitzer contends that Newsom's sweeping commutations were driven by personal opposition to capital punishment rather than individual case reviews, a stance he believes contradicts the will of California voters who have twice rejected ballot measures to abolish the death penalty.

"Our criminal justice system does not bend with the political winds, and one man – even if he is the governor – does not get to put his thumb on the scales of justice simply because he does not like the law," Spitzer said in a statement. He accused Newsom of failing to "faithfully execute" the law by granting mass clemency instead of evaluating each case individually.

Among the 18 inmates whose sentences are being challenged are individuals convicted of brutal crimes, including serial murder and child killing. These include Randy Steven Kraft, convicted of multiple murders between 1972 and 1983; Alejandro Avila, who kidnapped, sexually assaulted, and killed 5-year-old Samantha Runnion in 2002; and Eric Wayne Bennett, sentenced to death in 1997 for the rape and murder of Marie Evans Powell.

Newsom, however, has defended his actions, stating that the state constitution grants him clemency authority for "moments when law as applied cannot be squared with justice." He has maintained that his decision was a matter of conscience and that the commutations were issued to life in prison without parole.

This legal challenge is not the only opposition to Newsom's clemency decisions. The Criminal Justice Legal Foundation and several other district attorneys have filed a separate lawsuit. Additionally, victim advocacy groups have petitioned the state Supreme Court, requesting Associate Justice Kelli Evans recuse herself from reviewing commutations involving inmates with multiple felony convictions due to her prior work with Newsom on the state's execution moratorium.