Broadway Revival of 'The Imaginary Invalid' Falls Flat, Critics Say

The Roundabout Theatre Company's revival of Molière's "The Imaginary Invalid" at the Todd Haimes Theatre has been met with underwhelming reviews, with critics noting a distinct lack of humor. The production, which clocks in at 90 minutes with no intermission, features a cast that performers describe as working "very, very hard" but ultimately failing to elicit significant audience response.

Bill Irwin, who also adapted the play for this production, stars as Argan, the titular hypochondriac. Despite his deep connection to the text and expertise in clowning, Irwin's performance as Argan has been singled out as a disappointment. Reviewers note that his Argan is "scattered," with mumbled lines and off-kilter comedic timing, failing to land jokes even with props like pills and an artificial toilet sound effect.

The play centers on Argan's obsession with his ailments and the various characters vying for his attention and money. His daughter, Angelique, played by Ava Lalezarzadeh, wishes to marry Cleante (Daniel Croix Henderson) instead of the doctor's son Argan has arranged for her. Crystal A. Dickinson portrays Argan's scheming second wife, Beline, while Brooks Ashmanskas plays the pompous Dr. Diafoirus. The production's comedic setups, including Angelique and Cleante's secret communication through an improvised opera, are described as "no-brainer" yet are executed with a lack of impact.

Many of the supporting performances have been criticized as overly loud and grating, with one reviewer describing it as an "unpalatable silly voice contest." Ashmanskas's performance as Dr. Diafoirus is noted as his typical "here I am!" turn, and the scene involving Angelique and Cleante's disguised opera is called "terribly directed" with "dicey" singing.

However, Hiram Delgado earned praise for his portrayal of Thomas, Dr. Diafoirus's son, bringing an amusing "Revenge of the Nerds" spin to the socially inept character and eliciting genuine giggles. The standout performance, according to critics, is Rachel Bloom as Toinette, Argan's maid. Her simple delivery, crystalline diction, and witty, cutting remarks as she navigates the household's "nonsense" have been highlighted as a refreshing element in an otherwise unfunny production.

Brandon J. Dirden directed the revival, which opened on Thursday night. The set design by Beowulf Boritt has been described as resembling a "pre-crayon coloring-book."