express gazette logo
The Express Gazette
Tuesday, October 20, 2026

Bake Off Contestant's Nod to Mary Berry Sparks Fan Frenzy, Paul Hollywood's Reaction Debated

A baker's tribute to a former judge on The Great British Bake Off led to a flurry of social media commentary, with viewers speculating about Paul Hollywood's response.

US Politics • 2 hours ago
Bake Off Contestant's Nod to Mary Berry Sparks Fan Frenzy, Paul Hollywood's Reaction Debated

Fans of The Great British Bake Off expressed excitement Tuesday evening following a mention of former judge Mary Berry during dessert week. Berry, who judged the show alongside Paul Hollywood from 2010 to 2016, departed when the series moved from the BBC to Channel 4.

Baker Yannis revealed he would be using Berry's recipe for his sticky toffee pudding during the showstopper challenge. While the tribute honored the legendary cook, it was not enough to save Yannis, who became the fourth contestant eliminated from the tent.

Yannis's challenges throughout the week included self-saucing puddings that failed to impress in the signature challenge and an overly-flavored bread and butter pudding in the technical round. His dessert trolley showstopper, featuring a black forest gateau, trifle, and sticky toffee pudding, also fell short of expectations.

Connie was ultimately named Star Baker for her performance, which included earning a coveted handshake from Paul Hollywood.

The mention of Mary Berry's recipe ignited a strong reaction on social media, with many viewers on Twitter interpreting Paul Hollywood's demeanor as displeasure. Posts from viewers suggested Hollywood appeared "fuming" that a contestant would opt for Berry's recipe over his own or that of current judge Nigella Lawson.

This season has seen its share of challenges, with the previous week's bread week proving particularly difficult. A technical challenge involving flatbreads with a grape and blue cheese filling resulted in most contestants' bakes being undercooked due to the limited one-hour time frame. Hollywood described it as "probably the worst technical I think I have ever seen in 17 years."

Following the bread week judging, Nigella Lawson humorously suggested that the bakers should be made to eat their creations as a punishment. This remark was met with amusement by viewers, who speculated online that the judges might have sought out other food options after the disappointing tasting.

Mary Berry with Paul Hollywood Paul Hollywood looks 'fuming' Yannis using Mary Berry's recipe Yannis leaving the tent


Sources