express gazette logo
The Express Gazette
Saturday, October 31, 2026

Alaskan Voters Unswayed by 'Decoy' Senate Candidate Controversy

Despite allegations of a scheme to boost Mary Peltola's chances, voters indicate the controversy will not impact their decision in the race against Dan Sullivan.

US Politics • 2 hours ago
Alaskan Voters Unswayed by 'Decoy' Senate Candidate Controversy

Alaskan voters largely remain unfazed by a controversy alleging a scheme to influence the state's U.S. Senate race, with many telling the Daily Mail that the allegations will not sway their voting decisions. The controversy centers on claims that a candidate sharing the name of Republican incumbent Dan Sullivan was recruited by Democrat Mary Peltola's campaign and the Democratic Senatorial Campaign Committee to siphon votes.

FBI agents have reportedly contacted donors to the other Dan Sullivan, who has since disappeared from his home. The U.S. Attorney for Alaska confirmed that a civil lawsuit and a criminal probe are underway, though the specific crime under investigation has not been disclosed. The governor has also initiated a separate inquiry.

Peltola has denied knowledge of any campaign involvement in recruiting the candidate with the same name. "This is offensive to me on a number of different levels," she stated at a recent rally. She added that any former staff involved in such actions were let go for good reason.

Voters interviewed expressed mixed reactions to the allegations. Erika Monahan, who planned to vote for Peltola, called the situation "not ideal" but maintained it would not change her vote. She expressed greater concern about Sullivan's alignment with former President Donald Trump. Warren Richard Jones, an independent voter and former U.S. Marine, doubted the accusations against Peltola and suggested that even some Republicans might vote for her to express dissatisfaction with the current administration.

Cost of living, particularly the high price of gasoline, remains a central issue for Alaskans this election cycle. In August, gas prices in some remote villages reached over $26 per gallon, with a statewide average of around $5.

This Senate race has previously garnered attention in September when nine former Peltola staffers spoke to The New York Times, describing her as prone to anger and allegedly using offensive language. Peltola's campaign stated she regretted any inappropriate language used.

Jones acknowledged that he did not appreciate reading about Peltola's alleged outbursts but considered them a "no deal breaker," citing his familiarity with such language from his time in the Marines. Don Rearden, who attended high school with Peltola, agreed that Alaskans might be forgiving of language common among the state’s fishermen. He also dismissed the 'decoy' candidate situation as not newsworthy, recalling a previous election where an Independent candidate ran as Santa Claus.

Lauren Wolford, who has already cast her ballot for Peltola, stated that the controversy is "ridiculous" and that most people she knows are ignoring it. She noted that the ballot clearly distinguishes between the two candidates named Dan Sullivan: the incumbent is listed as Dan S Sullivan, marked 'incumbent,' while his namesake is Daniel J Sullivan.

Despite the clarity on the ballot, Donald Trump has suggested voters would need a "190 IQ" to understand the choice, alleging "fraud" and calling for Peltola and the other Dan Sullivan to be removed from the ballot. The Trump administration's Department of Justice has also sent letters to election officials nationwide, demanding the preservation of election records.

The controversy has drawn national attention, with the New York Times and the Associated Press reporting on the developments. The Daily Mail's interviews with Alaskan voters suggest that, for many, the unfolding saga has not altered their pre-existing voting intentions. IMAGE2 IMAGE6 Democratic hopeful Mary Peltola denied her involvement in recruiting the GOP incumbent Dan Sullivan's name double, who is also listed as a candidate for Alaska's Senate seat IMAGE7 Republican Senator Dan S Sullivan and other conservatives are trying to leverage the alleged political trickery to even stop the Last Frontier from certifying its election results, if Peltola wins IMAGE8 Donald Trump said that voters need a '190 IQ' to understand the ballot, although it clearly distinguishes between the two Dan Sullivans. According to the president, most people 'don't know what incumbent means' IMAGE3 US Attorney for the District of Alaska Michael Heyman said: 'Recent reporting has resulted in troubling new revelations' IMAGE4 The Alaskans the Daily Mail spoke to said the New York Times investigation did not change their minds on who they vote for


Sources