Several Adelaide football clubs have threatened to forfeit games against a team that includes transgender player Freya Golding, following the Australian Football League's (AFL) decision to allow her to continue competing in the women's league. Three clubs formally lodged duty-of-care complaints after an incident involving Golding, a utility player for Westminster Old Scholars, during a round five match.
The AFL's Gender Diversity Policy Committee reviewed the complaints but concluded that Golding's participation did not present an unacceptable safety risk. This ruling has led to potential action from the Adelaide Footy League.
"At our level, we are seeking counsel on what our rights are as an organisation to make a ruling as per the wishes of Adelaide Footy League Members," said John Kernahan, chief executive of the Adelaide Footy League. "And then underneath that, we have come to learn of a protest from clubs that if neither the Adelaide Footy League or the AFL can make a tough call, they will by way of forfeiting."
Kernahan expressed concern over the lack of definitive leadership from the AFL, stating it has created a contentious environment. He hopes the issue can be resolved before clubs resort to forfeiting, which he believes would be detrimental to the sport and the wider community.
Westminster Old Scholars were eliminated from the finals, meaning Golding would not participate in any further matches this season. The AFL has indicated that the decision is subject to review if new information regarding potential safety risks emerges. Generally, community footballers can compete in the category aligning with their gender identity under the AFL's policy, with competitive advantage alone not being a basis for exclusion at this level. However, individual players can be assessed if safety concerns are raised.
Golding has refuted claims of dominating opponents, stating she is not the largest player and rarely features among the best players. "I just want to play the sport I love with a great group of people," she told 9NEWS.
The AFL reiterated its commitment to fostering a safe and inclusive environment for all members of the football community. A spokesperson noted that referrals to the AFL Community Gender Diversity Policy Committee are handled in accordance with the policy, and players are generally permitted to continue participating if they do not pose an unacceptable safety risk.
The decision has drawn mixed reactions, with some sporting figures supporting transgender participation. Olympic swimmer Maddie Groves has previously advocated for transgender Australians' inclusion in community sports, while WNBL player Anneli Maley suggested that a lack of general support, rather than transgender athletes, is the primary challenge for women's sports.