Education Scotland, a government body overseeing the nation's schools, is facing criticism for proposing lessons to teach pupils how to identify errors in artificial intelligence-generated content. This initiative has drawn particular scorn because the organization itself has been found to have used AI in editing curriculum papers that were reportedly filled with significant mistakes.
Recent reports indicate that Education Scotland utilized AI to assist in the creation of papers meant to reform the curriculum. One of these papers controversially suggested lessons on pornography addiction for children as young as eight. The draft consultation document on literacy and English classes, which outlines the proposed AI lessons, states that information from AI-generated content "may contain inaccuracies, biases, omissions, hallucinations or outdated sources."
The framework suggests that students should learn to "confirm or dispute generative AI responses by comparing them to other information sources" and to trust information only when "supported by verifiable evidence that references its sources." The document defines an AI 'hallucination' as "invented content, presented as fact, which is incorrect or misleading." It also emphasizes teaching students the difference between misinformation and disinformation.
This push for AI literacy comes after concerns were raised by Brodie Runciman, a lecturer at the University of Edinburgh, regarding errors in several Curriculum Improvement Cycle papers. Runciman alleged that the documents contained fabricated references, non-existent sources, and incorrect citations. Education Scotland acknowledged these issues, stating they "acted promptly to rectify them and make the necessary corrections."
Former Downing Street adviser Chris McGovern, chairman of the Campaign for Real Education, criticized Education Scotland, saying the body had "made a fool of itself" and should "put its own house in order before lecturing others about the dangers of relying on AI." He added that ministers would lose credibility if they placed confidence in Education Scotland's advice on AI, suggesting that much of AI technology is "still in its infancy" and should carry a "trigger warning."
Similarly, Scottish Tory education spokesman Meghan Gallacher stated, "Education Scotland needs to get its own house in order before lecturing children about spotting fake information." She called the situation "utterly humiliating" and questioned whether the work was being properly checked.
Education Scotland maintains its commitment to transparency and responsible information use, asserting that the guidance "provides important support to help learners critically evaluate AI-generated content alongside all sources of information." A spokesperson for the Scottish Government acknowledged that errors were identified and corrected.
Earlier this month, a separate Health and Wellbeing framework document from Education Scotland was updated after initially including a call for lessons on tackling "addiction including but not limited to... pornography" for pupils in primary school. While the reference was removed in a later version, the reason for its initial inclusion and subsequent removal remains unexplained.