WWE's Nikki Bella-Paige Feud Lacks Strong Creative Direction
Attempts to inject drama into the rivalry are criticized for relying on superficial personal attacks rather than compelling storylines.
World Wrestling Entertainment (WWE) is facing criticism for its handling of the ongoing feud between Nikki Bella and Paige, with attempts to enhance the rivalry reportedly falling short. The current narrative is perceived as superficial, leaning on personal insults rather than developing a more robust and engaging storyline.
The absence of Brie Bella, who suffered a broken scapula, disrupted WWE's initial post-SummerSlam plans involving the Bella twins turning heel on Paige. This left WWE with the option to initiate a separate feud between Nikki Bella and Paige. While understandable, this sidestep has been noted as a missed opportunity, particularly with the potential to elevate emerging talent alongside the established stars.
Creative avenues that could have strengthened the Paige-centric storyline include focusing on Nikki's perceived jealousy. The narrative could have explored how Nikki betrayed Paige after Paige answered Brie's call for help when Brie's tag team partner was injured due to Nikki's own prior injury. This scenario would highlight Nikki's insecurity and jealousy over Paige's success in securing tag team gold, especially when Nikki's physical condition prevented her from participating.
Alternatively, if the focus remains on Nikki Bella's pursuit of a world championship, a more effective storyline could have involved Paige asserting her past superiority. Paige could have argued that Nikki's extended period of success was only possible because Paige herself was injured, emphasizing that Paige was always the more talented wrestler, a fact Nikki is aware of.