Mary Star of the Sea High School in San Pedro, California, is facing scrutiny from the California Interscholastic Federation (CIF) following the emergence of a video that appears to show five football players leaving the same residence. The video has raised questions about the team's eligibility as they are currently in the midst of a playoff run.
The school has denied any wrongdoing, stating that the student-athletes depicted in the video are international students residing at their approved home-stay residence with a local family. According to the school's statement, the home-stay family includes a father, mother, and a younger brother of one of the Mary Star students.
Tyler Sestich, the head coach for the Mary Star football team, addressed the rumors on social media. He responded to the viral video by posting, "Can’t wait to watch the breaking video of some international students leaving their host family house to go to mass in the morning 😂😂."
The Stars have had a successful season, finishing the regular season with a 9-1 record and securing a top seed in the playoffs. Since Sestich took over as head coach in 2024, the team has compiled a 28-7 record, including a 10-win season in 2024 and an eight-win campaign last year. The team is currently one win away from reaching the championship game and is scheduled to play Aquinas on Friday.
This situation brings to light past CIF rule violations by other California high school football programs, such as Norco High School, Orange Lutheran, and Bishop Montgomery. It remains to be determined whether Mary Star of the Sea will be found to have violated CIF guidelines.