Scotland's national football team has endured a "horror show" of a Nations League campaign under manager Sebastien Pocognoli, culminating in a comprehensive 4-0 loss to what is described as Switzerland's "B team" in St Gallen. This result and the overall performance have led to significant criticism, with questions arising about Pocognoli's suitability for the role.

Pocognoli, who took over in August, inherited a team that had previously qualified for major tournaments under Steve Clarke. His remit was to evolve the team's style of play and introduce a new generation of players, with the ultimate goal of helping Scotland progress further in major competitions. However, after six Nations League games, the record stands at two wins, one draw, and three defeats, with five goals scored and ten conceded. The wins came against North Macedonia, a team that lost all six of its matches in the group.

Scotland's performance against Slovenia also proved disappointing, with a draw followed by a 2-1 defeat at Hampden. The team lost 7-0 on aggregate to Switzerland across their two encounters. Despite Pocognoli's claims of positives and improved play, the prevailing sentiment is one of regression and a lack of clear progress.

Scotland's defeat arose from individual mistakes, a common theme during the Belgian's reign

Reports suggest that Pocognoli, who previously led Union Saint-Gilloise to a league title, has struggled to implement a more dynamic style of play or inspire confidence. While he is described as a likeable and decent individual who makes an effort to embrace the culture, there is a perceived lack of leadership and clarity in his messaging, which has led to frustration among players like captain Andy Robertson. The team has not met the "eye test," failing to consistently play on the front foot or create chances.

The Scottish Football Association (SFA) reportedly used data and AI in their recruitment process for Pocognoli, viewing his appointment as a coup. However, the data from the Nations League campaign paints a bleak picture. The team's poor performance means they will be placed in pot three for the Euro 2028 qualifiers, potentially leading to a more difficult group. Concerns are being raised about Scotland's chances of qualifying for Euro 2028, a tournament they are co-hosting.

Pocognoli was unable to inspire any resistance as his side succumbed to defeat in St Gallen

The current situation contrasts sharply with the perceived stability under Steve Clarke, though his departure after the World Cup also led to criticism of the SFA's decision to offer him a new contract. The current results under Pocognoli suggest a significant regression, leading to questions about whether the SFA should reconsider their decision.