With ten games of the Premier League season completed, the league's experts have offered their assessments of the campaign thus far, highlighting Brighton's Fabian Hurzeler as a clear favorite for Manager of the Season and identifying several standout players. The discussions also delved into predictions for the top and bottom of the table, surprise packages, and teams in most need of January reinforcements.
Manager of the Season
Fabian Hurzeler of Brighton has been overwhelmingly selected by the panel as the Manager of the Season. Experts cite his success in leading Brighton to second place in the Premier League, often playing an attractive brand of football while also managing the demands of European competition. "Hurzeler has taken the Seagulls to a different level," noted Ian Ladyman, acknowledging the team's strong form despite challenges. Jack Gaughan added that Brighton are "flying" and noted their victories over Arsenal and Manchester City.
Player of the Season So Far
The 'Player of the Season' discussion saw a variety of names put forward, with Brighton's Pascal Gross receiving multiple mentions. Matt Barlow described Gross as the "epitome of the Brighton formula," highlighting his confidence and consistent performance. Nathan Salt noted his league-leading ground covered and significant goal contributions, while Ian Herbert pointed to his "creative and organisational influence." Other players nominated include Fulham's Josh King for his dazzling displays, Liverpool's Ronald Araujo for solidifying the right-back position, and Arsenal's Martin Odegaard for his control and goal-scoring prowess. Brighton's Diego Gomez also earned praise for his spectacular goals.
Predictions and Underachievers
In terms of top-five predictions, Arsenal, Liverpool, Manchester City, Brighton, and Chelsea were frequently cited. However, concerns were raised about Manchester City's ongoing legal issues, with some experts suggesting a potential points deduction could impact their final standing.
The bottom three predictions often included Coventry City, Ipswich Town, and Crystal Palace. Coventry's current form and perceived lack of top-flight quality led to widespread predictions of relegation. "Fear Coventry will fade and Palace have simply lost too many good players for a managerial change to save them," stated Matt Barlow.
Manchester United were consistently named as the biggest underachievers, with criticism directed at both the boardroom and the players. "They are absolutely shocking from the boardroom to the pitch," said Nathan Salt, lamenting the club's current state. The team's struggles have led to concerns about their Champions League qualification hopes.
January Transfer Needs and Surprise Packages
Manchester United were also highlighted as the team most in need of the January transfer window, with urgent requirements for a striker and a left-back. Tottenham were also mentioned as needing a center-forward. Crystal Palace were identified as needing to bolster their squad to aid their survival bid.
As for surprise packages, Bournemouth and their manager Marco Rose, along with striker Evanilson, received praise for their strong performances. Hull City were also noted for exceeding expectations and holding their own in the division. "They've more than held their own so far," commented Nathan Salt on Hull's resilience.
Season-Long Predictions
Looking ahead, one bold prediction involves Manchester City facing a points deduction, potentially removing them from the top-five contention. Conversely, some experts believe Manchester United will improve and climb the table, while others foresee Nottingham Forest making a push for European qualification. The potential for fewer managerial changes this season was also suggested, bucking a recent trend.