NFL Week 11 features an unprecedented average point spread of 8.2, marking the widest margin seen in over two decades, according to BetMGM odds. This statistic underscores a widening chasm between the league's strongest and weakest teams, a trend attributed to a confluence of factors including quarterback injuries and a general decline in competitive balance.
The average closing spread through the first 10 weeks of the season was 4.71 points. However, Week 11's slate of 13 games shows a dramatic increase, with nine games featuring at least a six-point spread and five games with double-digit favorites. This is the highest average closing spread since at least 1999, surpassing the previous record of 7.75 points from Week 12 of the 2007 season.
Two matchups exemplify this disparity: the 8-1 Buffalo Bills are favored by 16.5 points at home against the 1-8 Miami Dolphins, and the 7-2 Kansas City Chiefs are 15.5-point home favorites against the 3-7 Arizona Cardinals. Other significant spreads include the 3-6 Houston Texans as 12.5-point favorites over the Indianapolis Colts and the 7-2 Chicago Bears laying 11.5 points against the 3-6 New Orleans Saints.
Quarterback Injuries Widen the Gap
A primary driver of these large spreads is the significant gap in quarterback quality, often exacerbated by injuries. The Bills, led by MVP candidate Josh Allen, face Kyle McCord, a rookie making his second career start due to Miami's injury situation. Similarly, the Chiefs, with two-time MVP Patrick Mahomes, are set to play Carson Beck, another rookie second-stringer for the Cardinals, who have also dealt with injuries to their veteran quarterbacks.
This quarterback imbalance extends across the league. Teams like the Baltimore Ravens are starting backup quarterbacks due to Lamar Jackson and Tyler Huntley being sidelined. The Philadelphia Eagles have turned to Joe Milton after Jalen Hurts' injury, facing a Pittsburgh Steelers team that is only a modest favorite despite the Eagles' quarterback situation.
The league's emphasis on protecting star quarterbacks, while intended to maintain the quality of play, also highlights their value. The presence of elite quarterbacks is seen as crucial for competitive matchups and the overall product of the NFL.
Decades of Playoff Futility and Parity Issues
Beyond the current week's betting lines, the disparity reflects a longer-term struggle for competitiveness among several franchises. Teams like the Colts, Dolphins, Cardinals, and Jets have endured lengthy playoff droughts. The Colts, for instance, have made the playoffs only once since Andrew Luck's retirement and recently parted ways with their general manager after nearly a decade.
The lack of parity extends to the Super Bowl picture as well. Over the past 13 seasons, only 11 different teams have reached the Super Bowl, with a few franchises dominating appearances. The AFC Championship Game, in particular, has been a near-monopoly for the New England Patriots and the Kansas City Chiefs since 2011.
This season's top contenders, including the 8-1 San Francisco 49ers and Buffalo Bills, and the 7-2 Chiefs and Cincinnati Bengals, suggest a continued trend of established powerhouses competing for the league's ultimate prize, leaving many teams with little realistic hope of reaching the Super Bowl.