express gazette logo
The Express Gazette
Monday, October 19, 2026

J.J. McCarthy's Performance Sparks Debate on Giants' Quarterback Depth

Rookie quarterback J.J. McCarthy nearly led a comeback win for the Giants after Jameis Winston was benched in Week 6.

Sports • 2 hours ago
J.J. McCarthy's Performance Sparks Debate on Giants' Quarterback Depth

Rookie quarterback J.J. McCarthy displayed a promising performance in the New York Giants' Week 6 loss to the New Orleans Saints, nearly orchestrating a comeback after starter Jameis Winston was benched. The performance has ignited discussion among analysts regarding McCarthy's potential impact on the team's quarterback depth chart.

During the game, McCarthy entered the contest and showed flashes of ability, driving the Giants towards a potential tie or win. His play has led some, including analysts Paul Schwartz and Brandon London, to question if he has surpassed Winston in the team's pecking order. The two also discussed other team developments, including the controversial benching of Cam Skattebo and the significance of the Giants' upcoming Week 7 matchup against the Houston Texans, which could be pivotal for their season.

Further details on the specific circumstances surrounding Winston's benching and McCarthy's full stat line from the game were not immediately available but are central to the ongoing conversation about the Giants' quarterback situation and their prospects for the remainder of the season.


Sources