express gazette logo
The Express Gazette
Friday, October 16, 2026

Football Fans Outraged by 'Worst Ever' Penalty Decision

A controversial penalty award for Partick Thistle has sparked widespread debate and disbelief among football viewers.

Sports • 3 hours ago
Football Fans Outraged by 'Worst Ever' Penalty Decision

Viewers have branded a recent penalty decision as potentially the "worst ever" after Partick Thistle was awarded a spot-kick under dubious circumstances. Former Scotland international James McFadden expressed his astonishment, stating "wow" during commentary.

The incident occurred when Oisin Smyth of Partick Thistle fell to the ground, seemingly without contact from Ayr United defender Kevin Holt. Referee Matthew McDermid subsequently awarded the penalty, which Smyth converted to give his team a 1-0 victory.

Even Partick Thistle's manager, Mark Wilson, acknowledged after the match that the decision to award the penalty was questionable.

The contentious moment has ignited debate among fans and pundits regarding the accuracy of refereeing decisions in football.


Sources