A second controversy involving alleged poor sportsmanship has emerged at the Over-60s World Cup in Canada, weeks after an incident involving a player nicknamed 'Clicky Ponting' gained international attention. In a match between England and India on Monday, England batsman Temoor Alam was given out leg before wicket (LBW) but refused to leave the field, prompting a lengthy delay and a subsequent reversal of the umpire's decision.
Alam, who had scored 30 runs at the time, initially indicated he had hit the ball before being given out. He remained at the crease for over 15 minutes, insisting he should not have been dismissed. Eventually, the decision was overturned based on his refusal to depart. Alam went on to score another 10 runs, finishing with 40, as England posted 167 for 7 in their 45 overs. England then dismissed India for 159, winning the match by eight runs, making Alam's extended innings crucial to their victory.
The incident has drawn sharp criticism from some observers. Those close to the tournament described Alam's actions as "an absolute disgrace" and "a blemish on our great game." One individual stated it was "the single worst incident I have ever experienced in decades of cricket." The controversy has gained traction on social media, with former South African cricketer Barry Richards commenting, "No. This can't be right. Life ban probably but certainly match forfeit."
Rashid Mahmood, the England commentator for the match, observed the situation live, noting, "He (Alam) is holding his bat out. He can't do that... Temoor Alam. You have to walk. You cannot do that. Off you go. You may not agree with it." He described the ensuing confusion among Indian players and the umpire's signal as causing "an absolute ruckus."
In cricket, if a batter is given out by the umpire, they are expected to respect the decision and leave the field. Alam's refusal to do so led to the reversal of the LBW decision after a significant delay.
This latest incident follows the viral controversy surrounding amateur cricketer Brian Devine of Saltburn, who was nicknamed 'Clicky Ponting'. Devine was filmed clicking his fingers while fielding to mimic the sound of a catch, attempting to deceive the umpire into giving a batsman out caught behind. Footage showed this tactic had been used repeatedly, leading to Devine's suspension by his club.
England Over-60's released a statement acknowledging the incident and stating that it is being "fully investigated." The organization noted that the video stream and commentary offered a "narrow perspective" and urged the public to avoid jumping to conclusions until "the full facts" are available. They promised a "full explanation as soon as possible."