England faces Argentina in a high-stakes World Cup semi-final on Wednesday, with a place in the final for the first time since 1966 on the line. Daily Mail Sport's panel of England experts has weighed in on critical selection decisions for manager Thomas Tuchel, particularly in midfield and defense, to counter the threat of Lionel Messi and his team.
Midfield Strategy and Player Fitness
Several experts debated the inclusion and positioning of midfielder Declan Rice, who has reportedly been dealing with injury and illness. Oliver Holt suggests keeping Rice and Elliot Anderson as a midfield screen to cut off supply to Messi, even if Rice is not at full fitness. He believes Jude Bellingham is too valuable further forward to be moved deeper.
Conversely, Ian Ladyman proposes dropping Bellingham alongside Anderson to help control the game, especially if Rice is laboring. He also suggests Morgan Rogers as an adequate No. 10. Craig Hope agrees that if Rice is fit enough to play, even for an hour, he should start.
Defensive and Winger Selection Dilemmas
The right-back position also saw varied opinions. Ian Ladyman advocates for Reece James, calling him England's best full-back, and believes it's time for him to play in his natural position. However, Craig Hope favors Djed Spence, citing his energetic performance off the bench against Norway and suggesting he is in better physical condition than James.
On the right wing, the debate continues between Bukayo Saka and Noni Madueke. Jack Gaughan prefers Madueke to start, believing Saka is more effective as a game finisher. Ian Herbert, however, pushes for Saka to start, emphasizing his ambition and attacking intent in the previous match, and also suggests starting Anthony Gordon.
Expert Opinions on Starting XI
Ian Herbert also suggested picking Spence over Nico O'Reilly due to his aggression and intent, and John Stones to mark Erling Haaland. He indicated Kobbie Mainoo would be the midfield choice if Rice is unfit.
Michael Owen's proposed lineup includes Pickford; James, Stones, Guehi, O’Reilly; Anderson, Rice; Saka, Bellingham, Gordon; and Kane. The experts' discussions highlight the fine margins and crucial decisions that could determine England's fate in the crucial semi-final clash.