Indianapolis Colts head coach Shane Steichen indicated a potential change at quarterback following the team's 26-3 loss to the Houston Texans on Thursday Night Football. The defeat dropped the Colts to a 3-8 record, and Steichen's remarks suggested a shift in his approach to starting quarterback Daniel Jones.
When asked about benching Jones, Steichen stated, "We’ll evaluate everything." This marks the second time in four weeks the coach has used this phrase when discussing Jones' status. In response to a follow-up question about Jones potentially playing against his former team, the New York Giants, in Week 12, Steichen added, "We’ll see. I’ll look into that. I don’t have that answer right this second."
The Colts' season has been largely disappointing since a Week 6 loss to the Tennessee Titans, a game that moved their record to 2-4. Much of the criticism has been directed at Jones, who is in the first season of a two-year, $88 million extension that could be worth up to $100 million. In his second season with the Colts, Jones has thrown seven touchdowns against 13 interceptions over 11 games.
His performance on Thursday night, completing 12 of 27 passes for 144 yards, continued a trend of struggles. This game marked his fifth consecutive outing with fewer than 200 passing yards and his seventh of the season. His Week 10 performance was particularly poor, with 11 completions on 22 attempts for 108 yards.
Despite these struggles, the Colts have been hesitant to move on from Jones. Steichen has faced consistent questions about Jones' starting position. After the Week 6 loss to the Titans, Steichen expressed support for Jones. Following the Week 7 loss to the Minnesota Vikings, he reiterated that Jones would remain the starter. After the Week 8 loss to the Jacksonville Jaguars, Steichen said he would "evaluate everything" before deciding on Jones' future, ultimately giving him another chance.
Following the Colts' Week 11 victory over the Miami Dolphins, Steichen noted that Jones would start the upcoming game due to the team being on a short week. However, with an extended break before facing the Giants in Week 12, the team may consider other options like Anthony Richardson or Riley Leonard.
"I thought he could do some things better, but obviously there’s a good pass coming at him, for sure," Steichen said regarding Jones' Week 11 performance. "But we’ll go back and evaluate the tape."
An additional factor in any potential decision is a $10.51 million injury guarantee for Jones in 2027, which activates if he is on the roster on the fifth day of the 2027 league calendar. This situation bears resemblance to a similar clause in Jones' contract with the Giants, which reportedly influenced his benching and eventual release during the 2024 season. A benching by the Colts could signal the end of his tenure with the franchise.
Jones acknowledged the team's offensive struggles, stating, "There’s always pressure in the NFL. I understand where we are as a team. I understand it’s an issue to score three points, and we’ve got to be better offensively. I’m the quarterback, and so I’m responsible. I’ve got to play better. I know that, and that’s the job."