express gazette logo
The Express Gazette
Friday, October 16, 2026

Celtic's Manager Faces Scrutiny After Europa League Defeat

Martin O'Neill defends his team's second-half performance despite a significant loss, but pressure mounts ahead of a crucial domestic fixture.

Sports • 2 hours ago
Celtic's Manager Faces Scrutiny After Europa League Defeat

Celtic manager Martin O'Neill found himself defending his team's performance after a 4-1 Europa League defeat to Benfica, a result that leaves the Scottish club without points after their opening two European matches.

Despite the heavy loss, O'Neill insisted he took solace from his team's second-half display. "We could have capitulated, but I thought in the second half we were terrific," O'Neill stated in his post-match press conference. "We created chance after chance. It’s not bravado on my part, I genuinely do believe we can still qualify."

The sentiment contrasted sharply with the reality of the match, where Celtic conceded three goals in the first 36 minutes. Jhon Duran opened the scoring with a penalty, Alexander Bah added a second, and Duran secured his brace before halftime. Former Celtic striker Chris Sutton described his old club as "flat-track bullies," highlighting a perceived lack of intensity in crucial matches.

Celtic's defending has been a point of concern, with the team conceding the most goals of any side in the Europa League thus far. In their last three European outings, they have shipped 12 goals.

O'Neill's tenure has been marked by past European successes, but the current iteration of the team has struggled in high-stakes fixtures this season. This includes defeats to rivals Rangers, an opening European loss to Ferencvaros, and now the heavy defeat in Lisbon.

IMAGE1:

"This is a manager who once elevated this club to the most extraordinary heights in Europe, now reduced to finding comfort in a belated response from his players after the contest had already been lost," one report noted. The article suggests that O'Neill's praise for the second half risks normalizing the earlier collapse and could send the wrong message to his players.

The focus now shifts to a crucial domestic fixture against Hearts. Anything less than a win, it is argued, will make O'Neill's position as manager increasingly difficult to defend. The pressure is mounting for Celtic to demonstrate progress and secure a vital victory.

IMAGE2: Auston Trusty despairs after Jhon Duran scores Benfica's second goal on Thursday night

IMAGE3: O'Neill was quick to emphasise Celtic's improved second-half performance against Benfica


Sources