Brazil's departure from the World Cup in the Round of 16, following a loss to Norway, has been described as an "unmitigated disaster." This marks a significant downturn for a team that reached the quarter-finals in the two preceding World Cups. The nature of the loss to Norway, where Brazil was comprehensively outplayed in midfield, has amplified concerns about the team's direction.
Coach Carlo Ancelotti assumed leadership after a substantial defeat to Argentina last year. In his 16 games, Brazil has secured 10 wins, three draws, and three losses. While Ancelotti managed to improve the team's performance after a difficult World Cup qualifying period where they lost four of five matches prior to his arrival, this has not been deemed sufficient.
The team's midfield, once a source of creativity and strength, is now seen as a primary area requiring fundamental change. The notes suggest a departure from imaginative central midfield play has alienated some supporters and contributed to recent losses. The perceived inability to match Norway's passing game was considered astonishing.
A key element of Ancelotti's strategy involved recalling Casemiro, who had been out of the international fold for 18 months. Casemiro's presence provided structure and allowed Bruno Guimaraes more freedom, though Guimaraes missed an early penalty against Norway. However, Casemiro's vulnerability in open space was evident, contributing to Brazil's deep defensive positioning that allowed Norway to build confidence through possession.
The absence of Lucas Paqueta due to injury in the previous round against Japan further complicated matters. Ancelotti admitted he lacked a player with similar characteristics. The subsequent inclusion of Gabriel Martinelli shifted the team's attacking approach to rely heavily on quick, direct breaks.
Criticism has also been directed at squad selection, including an initial call-up with only five midfielders, which is considered a significant oversight. The injury to right back Wesley in a pre-tournament warm-up game led to the inclusion of Ederson. While the coach faces blame, the broader footballing structure in Brazil is also being questioned.