express gazette logo
The Express Gazette
Friday, September 25, 2026

Alejandro Garnacho Faces Aston Villa Uncertainty Amidst Signing Doubts

The young winger's early struggles at Aston Villa raise questions about his transfer and future first-team prospects.

Sports • 2 hours ago
Alejandro Garnacho Faces Aston Villa Uncertainty Amidst Signing Doubts

Alejandro Garnacho's start at Aston Villa has been plagued by limited playing time and underlying concerns, echoing past issues the club has faced with loan players.

Despite an initially positive reception, with manager Unai Emery praising Garnacho's talent at his unveiling, the Argentine winger has accumulated just 31 minutes of game time this season. This lack of involvement has led to questions about his integration into the squad and his immediate prospects at Bodymoor Heath, the club's training ground. Few observers currently see a clear path to regular first-team football for the player.

There are also lingering doubts surrounding the specifics of Garnacho's transfer. The circumstances of his signing, including suggestions of a potential connection to Chelsea, have added a layer of complexity. This situation has drawn parallels to a previous season where Aston Villa reportedly paid a significant salary for a loan player they ultimately did not wish to retain, raising concerns about repeating a similar costly mistake.

Ominous signs have emerged from behind the scenes, contributing to the unease that would not please manager Unai Emery. Garnacho has been observed dawdling on the touchline when preparing to enter a match, indicating potential issues with readiness or understanding of matchday procedures. Alejandro Garnacho has had a miserable start to life at Aston Villa, featuring for just 31 minutes so far this season

Instances of his limited involvement are highlighted by his presence in the tracksuit during a match against Tottenham. He reportedly may not have even made the squad for that game had another player, Brazilian winger Alysson, been fit. There is no suggestion that Garnacho is disruptive but clearly he is not doing enough and right now few at Bodymoor Heath can see a path to regular first-team football

Despite the current difficulties, the possibility remains for Garnacho to win over his manager and the club. Emery has a track record of revitalizing careers, notably reigniting Marcus Rashford's form at Manchester United when the player had fallen out of favor. The challenge now is whether he can achieve a similar turnaround with Garnacho at Aston Villa. Not long after the final whistle in Aston Villa's 3-1 win at Coventry on September 16, Garnacho (pictured the week before) was heading out of the CBS Arena and en route to the Villa team bus

Fans and club officials will be watching closely to see if Garnacho can overcome these early hurdles and demonstrate the talent that led to his acquisition. Garnacho stayed in his tracksuit at Tottenham three days later, too, and may not even have made the squad had Brazilian winger Alysson been fit

The Villa boss reignited Marcus Rashford's career after he fell out of favour at Man United. Can he do the same for Garnacho?

‘We are delighted with Alejandro,’ said Unai Emery at Garnacho's unveiling. ‘He is so talented.' But that positivity already feels like ancient history


Sources