Sports network Beatline Sports is drawing widespread criticism for its use of artificial intelligence to generate over 300 daily podcasts and blog posts, many of which contain significant factual errors and questionable audio quality.
The network, which aims to provide daily, team-specific shows, has been accused of passing off AI-generated content as original work. A user claiming to be the founder, Ibnul Jaif Farabi, has openly admitted on X (formerly Twitter) that the content is not created by humans, stating, "If one person doing this 300+ sports podcasts daily, with custom created models and agents on CPU only, then you need to question your profession my guy. Compete or perish." Farabi also claimed the daily operational cost is minimal, around five cents.
Examples of the AI-generated content have surfaced on social media, highlighting numerous mistakes. On a podcast discussing the New York Jets, the AI referred to defensive end Will McDonald IV as "Will McDonald Four," a clear error that critics suggest a human analyst would not make. Similarly, a podcast on the Mets questioned whether the team's pursuit of pitcher Tarik Skubal hinged on the outfield defense of fictional players like A.J. Ewing and Carson Benge. Another clip on the Red Sox podcast suggested that a player like Jake Bauers might reduce playing time for the team's best hitter, Willson Contreras, an illogical scenario for a baseball front office.
Further examples include NWSL podcasts where the hosts share the last names of Hayes or Fletcher, and a soccer podcast that one writer described as "absolute rubbish and insulting."
Beatline Sports launched in August and its website states a mission to provide "honest, insightful analysis with just enough fandom to keep it real — grounded in real data, box scores, and reporting, not hot-take noise." However, the AI-generated clips often lack substance and exhibit a stilted conversational style, suggesting a lack of genuine human discussion.
In response to the backlash, Farabi has defended the venture, asserting its profitability and automation. He stated, "I make moolah, net positive, no work needed and totally hands off, so everyone's happy. Except some snowflake angry dudes on X."
