The Hayes Theater is hosting a revival of "The Fantasticks," the world's longest-running musical, which originally played off-Broadway for over half a century. This new production, directed by Christopher Gattelli, offers a significant twist: the two young lovers are now depicted as gay men, and their parents are reimagined as meddling mothers.
This gender-swapping approach aims to "iron out some of those ‘Mad Men’-era wrinkles" for a 2026 audience, as noted in a review from the New York Post. The original conception of the female ingenue, Luisa, and the fathers' obsession with their children's marriage, could appear dated to contemporary viewers. The shift in roles, while not fundamentally altering the show's narrative, "doesn't alter the bones of the piece in the same way that a similar maneuver did for Stephen Sondheim’s ‘Company,’" according to the Post.
The musical itself has a history of alterations, including a 2006 change to an "upbeat comic song that mentioned rape." This latest revision, however, is less about addressing problematic content and more about updating character dynamics. The new mothers are played by Leslie Rodriguez Kritzer as Mildred and Ruthie Ann Miles as Bessie May, who orchestrate a fake feud between their sons, Matt (Maxim Chlumecky) and Lewis (Nathan Levy), to encourage them to fall in love.
Ahmad Simmons portrays the actor playing the brick wall separating the two houses, a whimsical element of the original story. The score by Tom Jones and Harvey Schmidt, described as "jaunty and tuneful," remains a key asset. Chlumecky and Levy bring an "irrepressible modern energy" to songs like "Much More" and "Metaphor." Levy's portrayal of Lewis is noted for its hyperactivity, while Chlumecky's Matt provides a grounded presence.
Kritzer and Miles deliver campy and delightful performances, particularly in their duets. Their rendition of "Never Say No," which outlines their parenting philosophy, is likened to a "Borscht Belt" performance. Zane Phillips takes on the role of El Gallo, the narrator, singing the iconic "Try to Remember" with a soothing baritone.
The second act delves into the harsher realities that contrast with youthful fantasies, a theme that provides the show with its central point. Despite some narrative weaknesses in the latter half, which have been noted even since the show's initial run, the revival honors the musical's "humble origins" while incorporating "a touch of glitz" suitable for a Broadway production. Gattelli's direction is described as restrained, with an opening sequence that pays homage to the original off-Broadway staging.
While the production embraces contemporary updates, the review suggests that "fixating on its flaws is trite after five decades of success." The show's enduring appeal lies in its charming score and the relatable themes of love and fantasy versus reality.